Book an appointment

Make your own wedding ring workshop Learn more

Understanding Diamond Clarity. A Bespoke Buyer’s Guide

Understanding Diamond Clarity. A Bespoke Buyer’s Guide

Edward Fleming |

When commissioning a bespoke engagement ring or selecting a milestone diamond, clarity is often one of the most misunderstood of the 4Cs. At Edward Fleming Jewellery, where every piece is crafted to order in our central London workshops, we believe that choosing the right stone begins with clear, transparent education—free from industry jargon and sales pressure.

Whether you are considering a natural diamond formed deep within the Earth over billions of years or a modern laboratory-grown stone, understanding how clarity works allows you to allocate your budget where it matters most: visible beauty, brilliance, and enduring structural integrity.

What Is Diamond Clarity?

Diamond clarity refers to the absence—or presence—of microscopic natural characteristics inside the stone and on its surface. According to the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) Diamond Clarity Guide, these characteristics are divided into two distinct categories:

  • Inclusions: Internal characteristics enclosed within the diamond, or surface-reaching features that extend into the stone’s interior. Common inclusions include tiny trapped mineral crystals, pinpoint dots, clouds (clusters of pinpoints), needles, and fine internal fractures known as feathers.

  • Blemishes: External irregularities confined strictly to the diamond’s polished surface. Examples include faint polish lines, tiny surface nicks, scratches, or small patches of the original rough crystal skin (called naturals) left along the girdle.

Far from being mere "flaws," gemologists view these features as a diamond’s unique fingerprint. Because no two diamonds form under identical conditions, the pattern of inclusions plotted on a grading report serves as definitive proof of a stone’s individual identity.

How Gemologists Grade Clarity: The Five Factors

To ensure consistency across the global jewellery trade, major gemological laboratories—including the GIA, the International Gemological Institute (IGI), and HRD Antwerp—evaluate clarity under 10x magnification using a standardized jeweller’s loupe or microscope.

When assigning a clarity grade, a trained gemologist weighs five interrelated factors:

  1. Size: Larger inclusions have a greater impact on the clarity grade than microscopic ones.

  2. Number: A single tiny pinpoint is far less significant than a dense scattering of characteristics across the stone.

  3. Position: Location is critical. An inclusion positioned directly beneath the table (the large flat top facet) is much more visible—and can reflect multiple times through the facets—than an identical inclusion tucked near the girdle (outer edge), where a gold or platinum claw can easily conceal it.

  4. Nature: This refers to the type of inclusion and whether it affects the stone's durability. A deep, surface-reaching feather near an exposed corner carries higher structural risk during setting or daily wear than a tiny internal crystal safely encased in the heart of the diamond.

  5. Relief (Colour and Contrast): Relief measures how strongly an inclusion stands out against the surrounding diamond. A dark carbon spot creates high contrast and catches the eye far more readily than a translucent, colourless crystal of the exact same size.

The GIA Clarity Scale: FL to I3 Explained

Introduced in the 1950s, the GIA International Diamond Grading System remains the benchmark for diamond evaluation worldwide. The scale comprises six categories and eleven individual grades, progressing from completely pure to visibly included:

  • Flawless (FL): No inclusions and no blemishes are visible to a skilled grader under 10x magnification. FL diamonds are never visible to the unaided eye and are exceptionally rare, prized primarily by collectors.

  • Internally Flawless (IF): No internal inclusions are present, with only minor surface blemishes visible under 10x magnification. Like FL stones, IF diamonds are completely clean to the naked eye and appear visually identical to Flawless stones once set in jewellery.

  • Very, Very Slightly Included (VVS1 and VVS2): Minute inclusions are present that are so slight they are difficult even for a skilled grader to locate under 10x magnification. Never visible to the unaided eye, VVS grades offer near-perfection and high rarity without the steep premium of FL or IF stones.

  • Very Slightly Included (VS1 and VS2): Minor inclusions are observed with effort (VS1) or somewhat easily (VS2) under 10x magnification. To the unaided eye, these diamonds are almost always completely "eye-clean," making VS1 and VS2 the gold standard for fine bespoke jewellery and engagement rings.

  • Slightly Included (SI1 and SI2): Noticeable inclusions are visible under 10x magnification. While SI1 diamonds are often eye-clean and offer strong value when hand-selected, SI2 stones frequently display marks that can be seen without magnification.

  • Included (I1, I2, and I3): Obvious inclusions are clearly visible to the unaided eye and may affect the diamond's transparency, brilliance, and structural durability. As a result, these grades are generally avoided in fine bespoke commissions.

(Note: European laboratories such as HRD Antwerp and industry standards governed by CIBJO — The World Jewellery Confederation use equivalent tiers, referring to FL/IF as Loupe Clean (LC) and I1–I3 as Piqué (P1–P3).)

Understanding "Eye-Clean" Diamonds

In the bespoke jewellery studio, the single most important concept regarding clarity is whether a stone is eye-clean—meaning no inclusions are visible to the unaided eye at a normal viewing distance (roughly 15 to 25 centimetres) under standard lighting.

Because clarity is graded under 10x magnification, there is a substantial gap between what a gemologist detects through a loupe and what you see when admiring a ring on your hand:

  • FL, IF, VVS1, and VVS2 diamonds are virtually guaranteed to be eye-clean across all shapes and carat weights. Paying for these grades buys rarity rather than a visible difference in sparkle.

  • VS1 and VS2 sit in the sweet spot of value and visual purity. In round brilliant and fancy brilliant cuts under two carats, both grades appear completely pristine to the naked eye while costing significantly less than VVS stones.

VS1 Diamonds

VS2 Diamonds

  • SI1 diamonds vary widely from stone to stone. One SI1 diamond might harbour a cluster of white pinpoints tucked under a bezel or prong—rendering it 100% eye-clean—while another might feature a dark crystal right in the centre of the table. In our studio, we inspect SI1 candidates individually rather than relying solely on the paper certificate.

  • SI2 diamonds sit on the threshold of eye-cleanliness. While occasional SI2 stones in brilliant cuts under one carat can appear clean from a normal viewing distance, most display subtle inclusions visible to the unaided eye upon closer inspection—particularly in larger carat weights or open step cuts.

SI2 Diamonds

  • I1, I2, and I3 diamonds are rarely, if ever, eye-clean. In I1 stones, inclusions are readily apparent to the naked eye, often appearing as distinct dark crystals, white feathers, or cloudy areas. By I2 and I3, internal characteristics become heavy enough to visibly diminish transparency, scatter light poorly, and potentially compromise the stone's structural durability during setting or everyday wear—which is why we do not source these grades for bespoke commissions.

I1

I2 Diamonds

I3 Diamonds

How Diamond Shape and Carat Weight Affect Clarity

Not all diamond cuts treat inclusions equally. The faceting architecture of your chosen shape plays a decisive role in determining which clarity grade you actually need:

Brilliant Cuts (Round, Oval, Cushion, Pear, Marquise, Radiant, Princess)

Brilliant-cut diamonds are engineered with dozens of triangular and kite-shaped facets that fracture and bounce light in every direction. This intense scintillation (sparkle) acts as natural camouflage, easily disguising tiny VS2 or well-placed SI1 inclusions.

Step Cuts (Emerald, Asscher, Baguette)

Step-cut diamonds feature long, parallel rectangular facets and a wide, open table that creates a mesmerizing "hall of mirrors" optical effect rather than fiery sparkle. Because there is very little facet scatter to mask internal features, inclusions stand out much more clearly. For an Emerald or Asscher cut—particularly above 1.50 carats—we generally recommend stepping up to VS1 or VVS2 to ensure the stone remains crisp and unobstructed.

Carat Weight

As a diamond’s carat weight increases, its facets grow larger, acting like magnifying windows into the stone’s interior. A VS2 inclusion that is completely invisible in a 0.75-carat round brilliant may become faintly detectable in a 3.00-carat stone.

Natural vs. Lab-Grown Diamond Clarity

At Edward Fleming Jewellery, we work with both ethically sourced natural diamonds and certified laboratory-grown diamonds. Chemically, physically, and optically, both are genuine diamonds graded on the exact same 11-point clarity scale.

However, their internal characteristics reflect their different origins:

  • Natural diamonds commonly display tiny mineral crystals (such as garnet or olivine), natural feathers, and growth graining formed under geological pressure.

  • Lab-grown diamonds—produced via Chemical Vapour Deposition (CVD) or High Pressure High Temperature (HPHT)—may exhibit microscopic metallic flux inclusions (in HPHT stones) or subtle internal graining and pinpoint clouds (in CVD stones).

Because lab-grown diamonds are produced in controlled environments, higher clarity grades (VVS1–VS1) are far more abundant and carry a much smaller price premium over VS2 than they do in natural diamonds.

Balancing Clarity with the Other 4Cs

Clarity never exists in isolation. According to the GIA’s 4Cs Buyer’s Guide, Cut is the single most influential factor in a diamond’s overall beauty. A diamond with an Excellent cut grade will return maximum white light (brilliance) and rainbow flashes (fire), outshining a Flawless diamond whose proportions are too shallow or too deep.

When designing a bespoke piece in our Bloomsbury workshop, we advise clients to prioritize their budget in the following order:

  1. Cut Quality First: Always aim for an Excellent cut (or ideal proportions in fancy shapes) so the diamond radiates life from across the room.

  2. Colour Harmony Second: Match your colour grade to your chosen precious metal. Grades D–F (colourless) or G–H (near-colourless) look crisp and bright in platinum or 18ct white gold, while H–I stones blend seamlessly into warm 18ct yellow or rose gold settings.

  3. Eye-Clean Clarity Third: Select the lowest clarity grade that remains completely clean to your naked eye—typically VS1 or VS2 (or a carefully vetted SI1)—and let bespoke craftsmanship do the rest. Strategic claw placement or a sleek rub-over bezel setting can discreetly shield edge inclusions while securing the stone for a lifetime of wear.

Selecting Your Diamond at Edward Fleming Jewellery

Every diamond we source for a bespoke commission is accompanied by an independent grading report from a respected authority such as the GIA or IGI, complete with a detailed clarity plot mapping its unique internal characteristics. Even more importantly, we personally examine every shortlist of stones under natural daylight and studio magnification before presenting them to you.

Whether you are drawn to the rare geological history of a natural stone or the modern precision of a lab-grown diamond, our goldsmiths and gemmologists will guide you to a gem with extraordinary fire, structural integrity, and lasting value.

Search through 1000's of diamonds from IF to I3 using our diamond search tool.

Leave a comment